Choosing windows for a custom home
Stand across the street from a house you admire and look at the windows. Their size, their proportions, the depth of the frames and the pattern of the divided lights tell you what kind of house it is before you notice anything else. Step inside on a January morning and the same windows decide whether the sofa by the glass is the best seat in the room or the coldest. Few decisions in a custom home carry as much weight, and few are as hard to change later.
What are the main kinds of windows?
Most fine houses use one of four broad types. Wood windows have wood frames and sash inside and out, painted or stained, and suit traditional houses where the exterior trim and profiles matter most. Clad-wood windows keep warm wood on the interior and protect the exterior with a durable metal or composite cladding, which cuts down on exterior painting. Aluminum systems make the very large panels, sliding walls and thin frames that modern houses depend on. And steel and bronze windows offer the slimmest traditional profiles of all, with bronze chosen as much for its look as for its durability: it does not rust, and its warm, dark finish deepens with age, the subject of a separate entry.

What separates a well-made window?
On a custom residence nearly every opening is its own size, so a good window is built to order rather than chosen from a short list of stock sizes. Beyond that, the differences show up in the details. Look at the depth and shape of the sash and the profile of the exterior casing, which give a facade its shadow. Look at how smoothly the sash operates, and at the hardware that locks it. Ask how the exterior is protected, whether by paint, a metal cladding or a factory finish, and how that finish holds up to sun and weather. And ask what support the maker gives after installation, because a window should be serviceable for decades.
On clad-wood windows, not all cladding is alike. Extruded aluminum, pushed through a die into its final shape, is thicker and more rigid than roll-formed aluminum, which is pressed from thin sheet and dents more easily. The most durable finishes are factory-applied fluoropolymer coatings that meet the architectural industry’s highest performance standard for painted aluminum, AAMA 2605, and they need little more than an occasional rinse with clear water.
Size is where wood reaches its limit. A wood frame has to grow thicker as the glass gets larger and heavier, so the biggest openings, walls of glass and very slender profiles call for aluminum or steel, which are strong enough to carry large, heavy panes in a narrow frame. Specialist aluminum systems make glass walls with very large panes and narrow frames. Panels can slide and stack behind one another, tuck into pockets in the wall so a whole corner of a room opens to the outdoors, fold back like an accordion, or swing on a single pivot. In a Michigan winter these frames need to be thermally broken, and the sill deserves as much attention as the glass: a flush threshold that runs level from floor to terrace is beautiful, but it has to be detailed carefully to keep water and cold out. And where a design calls for the thinnest traditional profiles, steel and bronze windows are made by a small number of specialist makers.
The right window is the one that suits the house, performs in a Michigan winter and will still operate smoothly in thirty years.
How do you read a window performance label?
Every certified window carries a label from the National Fenestration Rating Council, and the Department of Energy explains what its numbers mean. U-factor measures how much heat the whole unit, frame and glass together, lets escape; lower is better, and it matters most in a heating climate like ours. Solar heat gain coefficient measures how much of the sun’s heat comes through; there is no single right value, because on a south wall some winter sun is welcome while a big west-facing wall may need less. Visible transmittance tells you how much daylight comes through, and higher means brighter rooms. Air leakage shows how tight the unit is, and lower is better.
U-factor
The number that matters most in a Michigan winter. It measures heat loss through the whole window, frame included, and lower is better.
Two windows that look alike can perform quite differently, and the frame is often the reason. Glass gets most of the attention, but the frame and the spacer between panes are where heat escapes and where condensation first appears on a cold night.

Details that make windows look right
The best window still looks wrong if the details are off. Divided lights should be true or simulated with bars on both faces of the glass, so they read as real muntins rather than a grid sandwiched inside. There is a performance trade-off: Green Building Advisor notes that true divided lights lose more heat, because heat escapes most at the edges of each pane, and that standard ratings are not based on divided-light units. Pane proportions should follow the style of the house, usually taller than wide on a traditional facade, as our entry on proportion describes. Exterior casings, sills and the depth at which the window sits in the wall all change how much shadow and substance a house has.

Installation is half the window
A window is only as good as its installation. Building Science Corporation and the Department of Energy’s Building America program describe the same principle: the flashing is layered like shingles, with a sill pan first, then the sides, then the head, so each piece laps over the one below and any water that gets behind the window is sent back outside. The gap around the unit also has to be sealed so it joins the house’s air barrier, a subject covered in our entry on airtightness. Large aluminum and metal units add weight, structural support and precise sill details to the list.

A good window disappears into the life of a house. You notice the view, the light and the quiet, and rarely think about the window at all.
Further reading: Building Science Corporation, RR-0407: Installing a Window with Building Paper on OSB over Wood Frame Wall; U.S. Department of Energy Building America Solution Center, Windows and Doors are Fully Flashed; National Fenestration Rating Council, What does the NFRC label tell you?; U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Performance Ratings for Windows, Doors and Skylights; Green Building Advisor, Thermal Break for Floor-to-Ceiling Windows and Windows: Glass, Ratings, and Installation.
Planning a house?
Thinking about a new home or a renovation? Start a conversation. More from our work, week by week, on Instagram.
All journal entries → Earlier: What building science means for a custom home →
The Journal shares general information about home design and construction for educational purposes. It is not professional advice for any specific property and does not replace guidance from a licensed architect, engineer or your local building department. Codes, products and site conditions vary, and recommendations change over time. Views expressed are those of the author. Reading this article does not create a client relationship with Mosher Dolan; any work we perform is governed solely by a written contract. Full Journal disclaimer.



